Warning: Full spoilers observe for Marvel’s What If…? by Episode 5.
On the subject of the Marvel Cinematic Universe’s tv exhibits, What If…? was all the time the wild card of the line-up. Sure, it’s the primary animated MCU providing, every episode to date is comparatively self-contained outdoors of the unifying gimmick of The Watcher’s restricted involvement, and it’s a group of multiverse tales relatively than an installment of the mainline universe canon. These are the plain solutions. However now that we’re a number of episodes into the primary season, a extra prevailing theme is turning into clear.
It’s the primary Marvel Disney+ present to really make the most of being a tv present.
Beforehand, on the MCU…
With WandaVision, The Falcon and the Winter Soldier and the primary season of Loki all within the bag, Marvel’s manufacturing ethos for his or her live-action exhibits has crystallized: They’re making six-hour films. This isn’t even a supposition on my half; Kari Skogland, the director of Falcon and the Winter Soldier, stated as such when discussing how she and Marvel Studios President Kevin Feige approached the collection: “I approached [it] like a movie. From the start, as Kevin stated, we had been making a six-hour movie.” It’s as plain an announcement of inventive intent because it’s attainable to make, and it’s additionally indicative of the pitfalls which have held these exhibits again from being their finest selves, as a result of they’re actively preventing towards the medium they’re in.
Other than the primary couple of black and white installments of WandaVision, it’s remarkably tough to differentiate the varied episodes in any of those exhibits from each other, or to recall what particularly occurs in every one. The narratives are segmented into episodes at comparatively random intervals and extensively differing runtimes, and this basic lack of a constant episode construction makes every one really feel imprecise as an installment in itself. This can be a recurring downside with lots of “paced for the binge” mini-series tv manufacturing within the final a number of years, but it surely’s an brazenly acknowledged a part of the mindset for creating these exhibits. The episodes of MCU exhibits should not distinct entities as a result of they aren’t designed to be. Past extra readily obvious issues like sluggish pacing and lack of thematic coherence, what this strategy additionally facilitates is the exhibits as an entire feeling largely inconsequential.
WandaVision begins with Wanda grieving over the dying of Imaginative and prescient, and ends together with her… grieving over the dying of Imaginative and prescient, however with a brand new costume and the added lack of their hypothetical youngsters. The Falcon and the Winter Soldier was basically a prologue to Sam Wilson accepting the mantle of Captain America, one thing the viewers may fairly be anticipated to deduce occurred between movies after being given the protect by Steve Rogers in Avengers: Endgame. Loki is mainly now in a pocket dimension with the TVA, and though the present is accountable for Kang’s arrival, he shall be correctly launched (and, we are able to assume, adequately defined) in his first movie look within the upcoming Ant-Man and the Wasp: Quantumania. It’s as if these collection are designed on objective to be ignored if the moviegoing viewers occurs to not have a Disney+ account, and whereas that’s sound from a enterprise perspective, it’s unsatisfying from a viewer standpoint as a result of the exhibits are so outlined by their MCU connectivity to the purpose of diluting their very own core narratives.
[Episodes] are allowed to be extra full as narratives as a result of they aren’t beholden to both constructing off of earlier threads or establishing future ones within the bigger franchise.
A Universe of Infinite Prospects
In distinction, What If…? couldn’t be farther from its brethren. Regardless of solely having a handful of episodes to its identify, What If…? has already cemented itself not simply as the perfect Disney+ Marvel present to date, however the first to firmly coalesce as each a tv present and an installment of the broader MCU, and it did so by not likely mattering to the broader MCU. Every episode of What If…? will not be solely a particular entity which are (to date, anyway) solely spiritually tied to one another by the present’s multiverse branding, they’re additionally allowed to be extra full as narratives as a result of they aren’t beholden to both constructing off of earlier threads or establishing future ones within the bigger franchise. That the person episodes may even be judged towards one another in any respect speaks to how rather more distinct they’re than the episodes from the live-action exhibits.
Whereas the primary episode will not be rather more than a gender-swapped remake of Captain America: The First Avenger as a approach to get the ball rolling, every subsequent one has created extra of a singular id, with the T’Challa-starring second having contemporary takes on an array of well-known MCU characters, and the third and fifth embracing wholly new genres as a homicide thriller and zombie apocalypse story, respectively.
However none have succeeded as far as a lot as Episode 4, which takes place in a actuality the place the dying of Christine Palmer was an inextricable a part of Physician Unusual’s origin story. This “absolute level,” because the Historical One calls it, is what Unusual seeks to reverse, main him down a darkish path that finally outcomes not simply in his personal ethical dissolution, but in addition the destruction of his complete actuality. As a tackle the Physician Unusual mythology, it’s a sibling to the movie as an alternative of a sequel, one which mirrors its live-action counterpart without having to behave as connective tissue to every part it established.
That is clear within the episode’s central conceit, which pumps up Christine Palmer’s significance to a stage that doesn’t match the movie’s use of the character in any respect. Within the film Stephen and Christine had been distant exes on the time of his fateful automotive crash, whereas within the episode their romance had apparently by no means died out. What If…? builds on Unusual’s central traits: his brilliance, his willpower, and his ego, however channels them in direction of an inevitably tragic conclusion.
The identical precept applies to Hank Pym’s likelihood to reconcile along with his daughter being ripped away, which turns him into an Avengers serial killer in Episode 3, and Imaginative and prescient’s emotional dependence on Wanda inflicting him to betray his beliefs by feeding folks to her zombified type in Episode 5. As for the Physician Unusual story, it ends precisely because the story wants it to: with Unusual alone, defeated, his world destroyed in precisely the way he was instructed it might. It’s a courageous and heartbreaking observe that stands in stark opposition to Unusual’s formative journey of accepting humility in his origin movie.
By being the “least vital” present to the broader universe, What If…? has mockingly wound up being the one with essentially the most real consequence.
Carlos Morales writes novels, articles and Mass Impact essays. You’ll be able to observe his fixations on Twitter.